|
Some interests
in legal history |
Apart from the general
information on legal history you might find it interesting to read something
about my own interests in legal history. My research and activities concern the
following subjects:
As a last item some of my
own publications. To my other historical interests belong for instance the
city and diocese of Utrecht,
and the Dominican
Order.
Nicolaus Everardi (in Dutch Nicolaas Everaerts)
(1462/1463-1532), a lawyer from Grypskerke near Middelburg in Zealand, presided
the Court of Holland in The Hague (1510-1528) and the Great Council at Malines
(1528-1532). Earlier he had been the ecclesiastical judge (official) for the
bishop of Cambrai and a professor at Louvain University. In 1516 he published a
manual on juridical argumentation, the "Topicorum sive de locis legalibus liber"
(Louvain: Thierry Martens). This book run through many reprints until the
mid-seventeenth century. In 1554 a collection of 247 of his consilia appeared
under the title "Responsa sive consilia Domini Nicolai Everardi de
Middelburgo..." (Louvain: Sassen and Birckmann). Here an unedited consilium of
him. Everardi presented more or less systematically the medieval doctrine on
juridical argumentation, but he made it also useful for students and legal
practicioners.
Literature on
Everardi
- Ten Raa, C.M.G.,voce "Everaerts, Nicolaas", in: Nationaal
Biografisch Woordenboek VII (Brussels, 1977) col. 214-23.
- idem, 'Nicolaas Everaerts (1461 of 1462-1532)', in: Zestig
juristen. Bijdragen tot een beeld der geschiedenis van de Nederlandse
rechtswetenschap, Th.J. Veen en P.C. Kop (eds.) (Zwolle, 1987) 97-103 -
sixty essays on Dutch lawyers.
- Kerckhoffs-De Heij, A.J.M., De Grote Raad en zijn
functionarissen 1477-1531 II, Biografieën van raadsheren (2 vol.,
Amsterdam, 1980) 69-70 - prosopographical research on the councillors of the
Great Council of Malines.
- Tracy, J.D., voce "Nicolaas Everaerts", in: Contemporaries of
Erasmus. A biographical register of the Renaissance and Reformation I,
P.G. Bietenholz and T.B. Deutscher (eds.) (3 vol., Toronto, 1985-1987)
446-447.
- voce "Everhard, Nicolaus, I", in: Biographisches Repertorium der
Juristen im Alten Reich 16.-18. Jahrhundert, Band E, F. Ranieri ed.
(Frankfurt am Main, 1987) 525-526.
- Wijffels, A., 'Iudicium Time', Rechtshistorisches Journal 3
(1984) 169-174.
- Feenstra, R., voce
"Everaerts (Everardi), Nicolaas (1461/62-1532)", in: Juristen. Ein
biographisches Lexikon. Von der Antike bis zum 20. Jahrhundert, M.
Stolleis (ed.) (Munich, 1995) 194.
Everardi
Consilia
Decretal
collections Lawyers
My
publications
|
Medieval
juridical advice: the consilia
genre |
Medieval juridical advice, most times called
consilia, have my great interest. As a historian they attract me: in them
the medieval legal doctrine is put into actual use to solve legal problems that
stem from questions in medieval society. Often they offer a fascinating and
sometimes the only window on it. Elsewhere on this site there is a bit more on
the
background of consilia. For the Low Countries, too, these kind of consilia
survive in the archives.
Literature on medieval legal
consilia (a selection)
- Falk, Ulrich, Consilia. Studien zur
Praxis der Rechtsgutachten in der frühen Neuzeit (Frankfurt am Main
2006).
- Legal consulting in the civil law
Tradition, Mario Ascheri, Ingrid Baumgärtner and Julius Kirshner (eds.)
(Berkeley 1999)
- Ascheri,
Mario, I consilia dei giuristi medievali. Per un repertorio-incipitario
computerizzato (Siena, 1982).
- Baumgärtner,
Ingrid (ed.), Consilia im späten Mittelalter. Zum historischen Aussagewert
einer Quellengattung (Sigmaringen 1995).
- Baumgärtner, Ingrid,
'Stadtgeschichte und Consilia im italienischen Spätmittelalter. Eine
Quellengattung und ihre Möglichkeiten', Zeitschrift für Historische
Forschung 17 (1990) 129-154.
- Dolezalek, Gero, voce 'Rechtsgutachten', in:
Handwörterbuch zur deutschen Rechtsgeschichte (HRG) IV, Adalbert
Erler and Ekkehard Kaufmann (eds.) (Berlin, 1986) 298-299.
- Gehrke, H., voce 'Konsilien, Konsiliensammlungen',
HRG II (1975) 1102-1105.
- Kisch, Guido, Consilia. Eine Bibliographie der
juristischen Konsiliensammlungen (Basel-Stuttgart, 1970).
- Rossi,
Guido, Consilium sapientis iudiciale. Studi e ricerche per la storia del
processo romano-canonico (Milano, 1958).
- Trusen,
Winfried, Spätmittelalterliche Jurisprudenz und Wirtschaftsethik
dargestellt an Wiener Gutachten des 14. Jahrhunderts (Wiesbaden,
1961).
- Wagner, Udo, 'Rechtsprechungs- und
Konsiliensammlungen. Niederlande', in: Handbuch der Quellen und Literatur
der neueren europäischen Privatrechtsgeschichte 2, Neuere Zeit
(1500-1800). Das Zeitalter des gemeinen Rechts. Zweiter Teilband: Gesetzgebung
und Rechtsprechung, H. Coing (ed.) (Munich, 1976) 1399-1430.
- Weber, R.J., voce 'Sapientes', HRG
IV (1988) 1298-1302.
- Zacour, Norman, Jews and Saracens in
the consilia of Oldradus de Ponte (Toronto 1990).
Everardi
Consilia
Decretal
collections Lawyers
My
publications
|
The
decretal collections of the twelfth
century |
The collections of decretals from the twelfth century form a
subject in the study of medieval canon law that holds also my attention.
Decretals, papal judgments in letter form on cases of ecclesiastical law, have
an intricate and complicated transmission before one finds them collected into
the great papal collections such as the Liber Extra of Gregory IX in 1234 and
the Liber Sextus of Boniface VIII in 1298. The early collections of individuals
with such decretals form a difficult but rewarding field of research, for which
the Institute of Medieval
Canon Law of Stephan Kuttner, since 1996 housed in Munich, is a very
important research institute. Elsewhere on my site there is an example of a
decretal from such an early collection.
Literature on twelfth-century
decretal collections
- Duggan,
Charles, Twelfth-century decretal collections and their importance in
English history (London, 1963) - review: Peter Landau, ZRG KA 51
(1965) 362-375.
- Duggan,
Charles, Canon law in medieval England (London, 1982) - reprints of his articles.
- Duggan,
Charles, and Stanley Chodorow (eds.), Decretales ineditae seculi XII. From
the papers of the late Walther Holtzmann (Città del Vaticano, 1982) -
reviews: Rudolf Weigand, AKKR 151 (1982) 631-634; Peter Landau, ZRG
KA 72 (1986) 411-414.
- Holtzmann,
Walther, Studies in the collections of twelfth-century decretals, edd.,
rev., transl. Mary G. Cheney and Christopher R. Cheney (Città del Vaticano,
1979).
- Kuttner,
Stephan, Repertorium der Kanonistik (1140-1234). Prodromus corporis
glossarum I (Città del Vaticano, 1937; Studi e Testi 71; several
reprints).
- Landau,
Peter, 'Die Entstehung der systematischen Dekretalensammlungen und die
europäische Kanonistik des 12. Jahrhunderts', ZRG KA 65 (1979)
120-148.
- Landau,
Peter, 'Dekretalensammlungen
des 12. und beginnenden 13. Jahrhunderts', ZRG KA 68 (1982)
453-461.
- Landau,
Peter, 'Vorgratianische
Kanonessammlungen bei Dekretisten und in frühen Dekretalensammlungen',
Proceedings of the Eight International Congress of Medieval Canon Law,
Stanley Chodorow ed. (Città del Vaticano, 1992) 93-116.
- Landau,
Peter, Kanones und Dekretalen (Goldbach, 1997) - reprints of articles
with additions.
Everardi
Consilia
Decretal
collections Lawyers
My
publications
Among the late medieval lawyers I concentrate on
Ludovicus Pontanus de Roma (1409-1439) and Nicolaus de Tudeschis (1386-1445).
Pontanus had a varied career in his short life, and he produced many works,
among them hundreds of consilia, of which I give an example. My
article on him provides a lot of information on him. De Tudeschis is
understandably much more famous than Pontanus : both have teached at Siena and
both were present at the Council of Basel. De Tudeschis was abbot of a
Benedictine monastery in Sicily, and in the end archbishop of Palermo. I have
also written about Giacomo Alvarotti and Baldus de Ubaldis.
Literature on Nicolaus de
Tudeschis
- Nörr, Knut-Wolfgang, Kirche und Konzil bei
Nicolaus de Tudeschis (Panormitanus) (Cologne-Graz, 1964).
- Black,
Anthony, Monarchy and Community: Political Ideas in the Later Conciliar
Controversy 1430-1450 (Cambridge, 1970).
- Jacob, E.F., `Panormitanus and the Council of
Basel', Proceedings... Strasbourg...1968, Stephan Kuttner (ed.)
(Città del Vaticano, 1971) 205-216.
- Pennington,
Kenneth, `Panormitanus's Lectura on the Decretals of Gregory IX.',
Fälschungen im Mittelalter, Bd. 2, Gefälschte Rechtstexte: Der
bestrafte Fälscher (Hannover, 1988) 363-373.
- Vagedes, J., Das Konzil über
dem Papst? Die Stellungnahmen des Nikolaus von Kues und des Panormitanus zum
Streit des Konzils von Basel und Eugen IV. (2 vol., Paderborn,
1981).
- Watanabe,
Morimichi, `Authority and consent in Church government: Panormitanus, Aeneas
Sylvius, Cusanus', Journal of the History of Ideas 33 (1972)
217-236.
- Riedel-Spangenberger,
Ilona, ‘Nicolaus de Tudeschis (Panormitanus, Abbas siculus, Abbas modernus)’,
Biographisch-Bibliographisches
Kirchenlexikon 6, T. Bautz (ed.) (Herzberg, 1993)
696-701.
- Niccolò Tedeschi (Abbas Panormitanus)
e i suoi Commentaria in decretales, a cura di Orazio Condorelli (Rome
2000) - a volume of essays,
with a bibliography on Panormitanus.
- Pennington, Kenneth, Nicolaus
de Tudeschis - an online article with many references to manuscripts,
editions and literature.
Everardi
Consilia
Decretal
collections Lawyers
My
publications
|
Some of my
own publications |
- 'Waar stad en platteland elkaar
ontmoeten. Tolsteeg, een Utrechts buitengerecht in de vijftiende eeuw' ["Where
city and countryside meet each other. Tolsteeg, an extramural jurisdiction of
Utrecht in the 15th century"], Jaarboek Oud-Utrecht 1990, 39-57.
- Studies over Nicolaas Everaerts
(1462-1532) en zijn Topica ["Studies on Nicolaus Everardi (1462-1532) and
his Topica"] (Ph.D. thesis Rotterdam; Arnhem 1994).
- ‘Werken
op zondag? Middeleeuwse juristen en werkverslaving’
["Working on Sunday? Medieval lawyers and work addiction"], Madoc 8/3
(1994) 159-163 - on Giacomo Alvarotti's views; online at the Digitale Bibliotheek der Nederlandse Letteren [Digital Library of Dutch Literature] (DBNL).
- ‘Van
stof tot gewaad. Adviezen over kleding van Adriaan Boeyens en Nicolaas
Everaerts’ ["From cloth to dress. Advice on clothing by Adriaan Boeyens and
Nicolaus Everardi"], Madoc 12/4 (1998) 257-262 - Adrian Boeyens became
pope Adrian VI (1522-1523); online at the DBNL.
- ‘Vita
brevis, opera multa: Ludovicus Pontanus de Roma (1409-1439), a prolific
writer’, in: Verein Junger Zürcher RechtshistorikerInnen,
¿Rechtsgeschichte(n)? ¿Histoire(s) du droit? ¿Storia/storie del diritto?
¿Legal Histori(es)?, [M. Luminati e.a. (eds.)] (Frankfurt am Main, etc.,
2000) 165-175.
- ‘Bibliography
of Stephan Kuttner (1907-1996)’ and ‘Bibliographie
von Stephan Kuttner (1907-1996)’ [German version] - the publications of
the founder of the Institute of Medieval Canon Law, now in
Munich.
- 'Argumentation
in practice: Nicolaus Everardi (1462-1532) on canon law and custom in the Low
Countries', in: Proceedings of the Tenth International
Congress of Medieval Canon Law, Syracuse, New York, 13-18 August 1996,
Kenneth Pennington, Stanley Chodorow and Keith H. Kendall (eds.) (Città del
Vaticano 2001) 635-650.
- Santiago
en Utrecht. Uit de geschiedenis van het Utrechtse Jacobsgasthuis en de beide
Jacobsbroederschappen ["Santiago and Utrecht. From the history of the
Utrecht pilgrims house of St. James and the two Saint James' confraternities"]
(Utrecht 2002).
- ‘Tussen stadstaten en signori : Baldus de
Ubaldis, jurist van formaat in veertiende-eeuws Italië’ ["Between city states
and signori : Baldus de Ubaldis, a formidable lawyer in fourteenth-century
Italy"], Madoc 16/3 (2002) 141-149 - an overview of recent publications
on Baldus showing the diversity of his work.
- 'Middeleeuwse sporen van Utrechtse pelgrims naar Santiago' ["Medieval traces of pilgrims to Santiago from Utrecht"] , Tijdschrift Oud-Utrecht 84 (2011) 104-108.
- Arguing the law with Nicolaus Everardi, http://rechtsgeschiedenis.wordpress.com, 2011 - on digital versions of editions of Everardi's works
On my blog you will find more short articles and notices which I have written since December 2009.
Everardi
Consilia
Decretal
collections Lawyers
My
publications
ov - November 7, 2011